A Paleoindian(?) Spearpoint Made From a Flake: A Chipped Stone Controversy
A spearpoint from Enoch Fork Rockshelter is at the center of a controversy. Is it a Paleoindian period tool or one that was made much later?
The jury is still out. But if it is Paleoindian, then it is one of the oldest tools in Kentucky and possibly the oldest tool recovered from a Kentucky rockshelter.
Investigators encountered it toward the bottom of the cultural deposits. They found it below Early Archaic (8000-6000 BC) period Kirk Stemmed spearpoints and above deposits from which they had secured a radiocarbon date of 10,956 BC. This suggests it could be a Paleoindian spearpoint.
The problem, however, is that the ancient Native flintknapper made this point from a flake (a piece of stone removed from a larger stone during toolmaking). These flakes are often long and thin.
This point has a deeply notched base. The knapper ground down the base to prevent it from cutting the material used to attach it to the spear shaft. The sides of the base are straight, and the base has two prominent ears. The tool's sides curve inward, then expand outward to form the blade. A Native flintknapper clearly had resharpened the blade.
Paleoindian flintknappers commonly made spearpoints from blanks they had worked on both sides, not from flakes worked on only one side. For this reason, many archaeologists do not think the Enoch Fork tool is a Paleoindian spearpoint. And so, they do not recognize the site's significance. However, researchers in other states have classified similar spearpoints made from flakes as Paleoindian spearpoints.
The evidence from Enoch Fork seems clear. Characteristics of the tool itself and the location from which it was recovered show that the Enoch Fork Rockshelter tool is one of the oldest ever made in Kentucky.